Friday, October 17, 2008

A reminder to the teachers at the kindergarten.

Mia came home with some drawings for me yesterday. I've included them here. Just to illustrate the difference between what happens at home and what is happening at school. I could'nt help myself and have just completed a letter to the head teacher of which I include a copy here as well. I just can't say nothing.







Dear Kindergarten Teachers

It is with regret that I am writing this letter, but I hope it will be received in the spirit of better education.

I have noticed recently (more and more) that there are some teacher led activities which involve showing children how to draw something. I refer in particular to a table set out with a teacher-drawn flower which some children were trying to copy, with the teacher present, assisting the process: “…And what about some leaves coming off the stem like this…?”. Considering the plethora of flowers brought in by children for their teachers every day of various shapes and sizes, wouldn’t setting them all upon a table and encouraging the children to look at the real thing be a better exercise? Just the other day my children brought in blue irises which are spectacularly colourful and different to the typical stem, leaf and daisy type flower we all draw now (thanks to having our creativity quashed when we were young and malleable).

I know it can be hard to say no to a child when they ask you to draw something, but we all should try harder.

Where have the informative notices that were on display before gone? The ones about a child’s developmental drawing stages (eg. A circle head with arms and legs. ) They served as wonderful educational tools for parents and teachers alike and were of great reassurance to me to know that we shared the same beliefs. Some of the examples up on display were delightful.

It’s so easy to spot a teacher-assisted or –led drawing, There’s no magic in it.

Similarly, where have the notices and reminders gone about parents/teachers not drawing on the children’s artwork?

I know there have been new teachers arriving over the last couple of terms and perhaps this letter will be the catalyst to revisit the values that I considered vital when I enrolled my children here. This beautiful creative, fresh, innocent and unique creative phase of our children’s lives occurs only now, and I invite you and your team to recognize the value of these expressionist artworks that happen every day and to nurture and cherish them as you did before.

5 Comments:

At 11:16 pm, October 17, 2008, Anonymous Anonymous said...

omg, linda - that is really tragic. i really hope they'll take your brilliant letter in the spirit with which it's meant and then ACT upon it. people just don't seem to realise there's anything wrong with showing a child how to draw - it seems so obviously wrong, but perhaps only more obvious to those of us under the schimmel influence... i really hope that all the freedom of expression you've encouraged in your children will shine through after they've experienced the didactic drawing lessons from their ignorant teachers. i'm sure you won't let this one go...
good luck.

 
At 7:58 am, October 19, 2008, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I agree with Belinda. Perhaps you can explain to the teachers that a child draws before they have any other means of expression and that what they draw is a direct link with their emotional, physical and spiritual stage of development. Therefore, if they stint this precious avenue of expression by imposing adult standards of how things "look" instead of praising the child's magical expressive way of drawing (based on EXPERIENCE rather than realism) they actually rob the child of self esteem and confidence. I am sure that this is not what the teachers want. They simply have not been taught properly during their training. And, subsequently they think that they are doing the right thing.
I am proud of you for writing your letter. Very proud.
Also remember that Mia is now moving into the pre-schematic stage where they use symbols that stand for things and eventually develop symbols for people, flowers, houses, animals, birds (m birds for instance) in favour of their beautiful previous, magical imagery. This is usually the end of their most creative stage in their lives. A shame. However, with sensitive teachers and parent and grand parents and nannies, their natural creativity can be nurtured through this stage.
Good luck in continuing the mission.
with all my love and admiration
your mother, the art educator.

 
At 9:20 am, October 20, 2008, Blogger linda said...

Mom anon
Perhaps, instead of a book, you could write your own blog? All about this issue?

What do you think?
:)

Thank you for your response. I do intend to keep them in check about this issue, because Joshka will be there for the next 2 years as well.

 
At 11:50 pm, November 11, 2008, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Did you get any feedback from the kindergarten?
Tessa.

 
At 7:12 am, November 12, 2008, Blogger linda said...

Yes, it was well received - thank goodness, and I continue to keep an eye out. It's very hard and the damage has been done. But hopefully Mia's magical drawings will reappear over the Christmas holidays.

http://pagedesign-linda.blogspot.com/2008/10/well-received.html

 

Post a Comment

<< Home